Committee Resources
Judicial Endorsements and the First Amendment: The Implications of the Ohio Supreme Court’s Holding That the Canon of Judicial Ethics Rule Barring Such Endorsements Is Unconstitutional
Over fifteen years ago, The American College of Trial Lawyers (“the College”) issued a white paper opposing contested elections for the selection and retention of judges in all instances. Asserting that “the ‘appearance of impartiality’ is critical to judicial independence,” the College argued that “contested judicial elections, including retention elections, create an unacceptable risk that improper and deleterious influences of money and politics will be brought to bear upon the selection and retention of judges.”
Threats to Impeach Judges for Judicial Decisions Undermine the Rule of Law
Any effort to diminish the independence of the decision-making process undermines a vital element of our judicial system.
Recommendations for a Senate Special Committee on Judicial Nominations
A leading responsibility of the American College of Trial Lawyers is to educate the public on the judiciary’s role in protecting the rule of law. The committee recommends eleven measures to guide the Senate in securing needed reform.
The Need to Promote and Defend Fair and Impartial Courts
In this report, a sequel to Judicial Independence: A Cornerstone of Democracy Which Must Be Defended, the College looks back at the past decade to evaluate the collective efforts of the College and others in our profession to meet the goals the 2006 Report set out.
Judicial Independence: A Cornerstone of Democracy Which Must Be Defended
Any perceived threat to judicial independence should summon the legal profession to action. Lawyers must recognize genuine threats to judicial independence and, when they arise, call attention to them and confront them.